Villarreal’s decision to replace Marcelino following a third-place finish in La Liga and back-to-back Champions League qualifications certainly raised a few eyebrows. However, that choice did come on the back of a woeful European campaign, coupled with the opportunity to appoint arguably Spain’s most highly rated young coach in the shape of Iñigo Perez.
While risky given their consistency in league football under Marcelino, the logic behind the appointment of the ex-Rayo Vallecano boss was sound. Fresh from unexpectedly steering the Madrid club to a Conference League final, Perez was viewed as the man who could bring more exciting football and better results in Europe to the Estadio de la Ceramica.
However, with just six wins from 17 competitive games so far, one of which was against minnows Manacor in the Copa del Rey, Perez is already starting to come under pressure. The Yellow Submarine have lost more matches than they’ve won in La Liga, while they’re again struggling in the Champions League.
Villarreal were 4-0 down inside 17 minutes at home against PSG last time out in Europe, in a game they went on to lose 6-0. It felt like a potential breaking point for the entire Perez project.
Strong underlying data
While viewed as a steady, well-run club by many in Spain, Villarreal haven’t been afraid to make coaching changes when things haven’t been going well. They fired both Quique Setien and Pacheta before the turn of the year in the 2023/24 season, prior to a period of greater stability under Marcelino.
It’s therefore not safe to assume that they will automatically give Perez the time he might need to turn things around. The 38-year-old would certainly have breathed a sigh of relief when Tajon Buchanan and Carlos Romero scored late goals to seal a 2-0 win over Getafe in their final outing before the international break.
The underlying data in La Liga remains quite positive for Villarreal. They rank third with their tally of 24.4 xG, while their xGD (expected goal difference) of +11.5 also places them behind only Real Madrid and Barcelona, and well clear of Atletico Madrid’s +5.5.
Creating opportunities has not been a major issue, and even their underlying defensive figures are also surprisingly encouraging. The Yellow Submarine rank third in the Spanish top flight behind Real Madrid and Celta Vigo, having only allowed 12.9 xG.
By just about any measure, Villarreal have been La Liga’s biggest xG underperformers this season. That does suggest that Perez has got his core ideas across to this group of players and that they’re executing many of those well. However, it’d be a real stretch to claim that this team’s struggles have merely been down to bad luck.
Fundamental flaws remain
Boosted by an influx of Champions League cash for the second year in a row, Villarreal’s failure to address problem positions in the transfer market this summer remains baffling.
At the very top of that particular list is the goalkeeper position. Luiz Junior seldom looked like the answer during his first two seasons in Spain and his stock reached new depths with a nightmare display against Deportivo A Coruña in September, which led to him being loudly jeered by the Ceramica and subsequently dropped by his boss.
Doubts also linger about the defence, particularly on the Champions League stage, but a lack of domestic clean sheets also remains a concern. Villarreal failed to shut their opponents out in any of their final 14 La Liga fixtures last season, but they opted against signing a single defender in the summer transfer window. Carlos Romero did return from a successful loan spell at Espanyol, but the left-back is yet to find the form he showcased at the RCDE Stadium.
Finding the right formula in the final third has also so far eluded Perez. He doesn’t lack striker options, with Georges Mikautadze, Gerard Moreno, Tani Oluwaseyi and Ayoze Perez vying for places, while Nicolas Pepe can also operate up front.
However, those players have contributed a combined total of just eight goals in La Liga so far. Perez has used both 4-4-2 and 4-2-3-1 systems, but none of his main attackers have found any real rhythm in front of goal.
The games that could make or break Perez’s reign
Villarreal have five league fixtures and two Champions League matches to fit in before the end of the year. After an underwhelming start, it will be a crucial period that could give Perez the foundations he needs to kick on.
Should his team’s fortunes fail to improve, the Yellow Submarine boss will likely find himself fighting for his job by the end of the year.
Villarreal’s remaining fixtures in 2026:
| Date | Fixture | Competition |
|---|---|---|
| 22 Nov | Barcelona (a) | La Liga |
| 25 Nov | Slavia Prague (a) | Champions League |
| 29 Nov | Celta Vigo (a) | La Liga |
| 5 Dec | Real Sociedad (h) | La Liga |
| 8 Dec | Sabah (h) | Champions League |
| Weekend of 12/13 Dec | Rayo Vallecano (h) | La Liga |
| Weekend of 19/20 Dec | Osasuna (a) | La Liga |
Things don’t get any simpler for Villarreal as they return from the international break with a trip to Camp Nou. A free hit perhaps, but Perez did get some positive results against the “big three” during his time in charge of Rayo. It’s also worth noting that the Yellow Submarine have won on three of their previous five league visits to Barcelona.
While a positive result could act as a turning point, the Barca game likely won’t make or break Villarreal’s season. By contrast, their subsequent fixtures could well do just that.
It’s not an easy end to the year in La Liga for Villarreal. Following the trip to Camp Nou, they travel to Vigo and then host an in-form Real Sociedad side. Perez then rounds the year off with meetings against his former clubs Rayo Vallecano and Osasuna. It’d be a particularly cruel twist of fate should either inflict the defeat that could potentially bring his reign to an end.
The next two Champions League fixtures are also absolutely vital in terms of Villarreal’s hopes of progressing into the knockout stage. They take on Slavia Prague (34th) and Sabah (31st) before the year is out.
Maximum points across those games would kickstart the Yellow Submarine’s European campaign and leave them on the brink of a place in the knockout phase play-off round. However, defeats against the likes of Pafos and Copenhagen in last season’s competition will still be fresh in the memory of many players.
Time may be running out for Perez unless he can start to translate some of the positive aspects of his reign to date into regular results. The coming weeks will offer a clearer indication of whether Villarreal are simply enduring a difficult transition under a promising young coach, or whether the gamble to move on from Marcelino was a costly mistake.
Mark Sochon is an experienced football writer and has been the editor of LaLigaExpert.com since 2018. Based in Madrid, he has been covering La Liga and Spanish football for more than a decade. Aside from writing most of the content here, he also covers La Liga and European competitions for Goal and Betfred, while his work has previously been published by the likes of the Guardian and World Soccer.
During his time in Spain, he has travelled up and down the country, attending matches in virtually every top-flight stadium. His areas of expertise include data-led match predictions and probability analysis, as well as Spanish football team news, with La Liga predicted lineups researched and published each week. | Follow Mark Sochon on X